Monday, 29 August 2011

Sunrise: A Song Of Two Humans

Friedrich Wilhelm Murnau - 1927
Murnau uses some pretty distant framings at times. Most notably, putting the couple low down in the frame, and using the top. He creates some of the greatest images in the cinema with the somplexity of the lighting, and this tiered composition, in the dance hall sequence. He also uses variations for entirely different effects, for loomings and overhangings, of the vamp near the end, for example.
Pictorially, the off-centre hard backlight provides beyond beautiful images. Murnau won't cut on these too quickly. This allows for two of the greatest performances of the cinema; not overdone, full of nuance and depth (whatever that is...), but also clear and simple, of the country folk.
Their is really a plethora of effects here, that would be verging on ridiculous anywhere else, but are used so perfectly to work. Endless impositions, of a city, a dream, cinema across time. And of course the wonderful movement. We have slow tracks, so smooth, so sensual, that are, yes, erotic, in a more gentle than brutal way. The horizontals across the city, at once calm but wildly exciting.
This is what the city is; the place of beauty, coming from the tram window (simple, but sharp), surrounding with love, with hope. But often the place of predators, despair, the couple caight in the traffic, for all the beauty, across time and space, of their tracking walk through it. The city is at once the storm, but how can one live without it?
What is 'Sunrise'? It is the most beautiful day of our life. And with that I take a short break to these entries.

Akasen Chitai

Kenji Mizoguchi - 1956
Known as 'Street Of Shame'... Mizoguchi isn't quite so much for the closer views in here is very last. It is however pretty busy, often compartmentalised, as we go through the different prostitutes. There are some great shots of the street, always of course in long. Of course the singular use Mizoguchi makes of off-screen space, not only in still eyelines, but how characters come from somewhere, walk through, leave on the other end.
Mizoguchi's sheer sympathy is remarkable; there are more simple things to say than the obvious, the hatred of what they do. It is difficult to love them and not then defend what they do, but I felt the balance was struck. Perhaps partly due to the narrative strategy; slow unfoldings of pretty clear stories.

Yokihi

Kenji Mizoguchi - 1955
In colour? Whatever next. Pretty well lit, I rather liked the paleness in the whole situation; especially in the water, and the bathing pools, and the bathing robes.
Sacrifice is centered here. It is at once political, but really I felt more of the pull of the personal here; ideas of transformation, who one is really connected to, and the love that crosses all, across real time, across cuts of the cinema.

Chikamatsu Monogatari

Kenji Mizoguchi - 1954
This is one of the busier of Mizoguchi's works I have seen. The close views aren't too obvious, but the long takes are, in the enclosed rooms, and later the enclosed forests, that I'm coming to associate, with the twinkling lights that just creep around, with Mizoguchi. Again we have tragic love, the figure of the women as the noble survivor, the good natured by rather weak man, and the evil man.
Mizoguchi and Deleuze (did the latter write on the former?); there's a weird combination. Here's my thinking. Mizoguchi is known as taking a relation to emotion that is not direct sympathy. In earlier entries I have talked about swirling effects in Mizoguchi, the idea of the lack of specificity ('A' Emotion / 'A' Life) in this portrayal. Add to this what I keep coming across in Mizoguchi (but forgot to mention in earlier entires); the idea of excess. His females, looking for love generally, for cosy home life, are, frankly insane. They are insane masochists. In Oyu-Sama the younger sister originally basically commits herself to a life of misery for another, giving more than she has; excess. Look at the face of Zushio as he goes to the advisor in Sancho Dayu. The idea od mysticism in Mizoguchi, excess, love beyond the exchnage principle, the sacrifice of this, the end of 'Ugetsu Monogatari'. For all the decorum, his is a cinema of insanity. But portrayed quite calmly.

L'Annee Derniere A Marienbad

Alain Resnais - 1961
Let's mention the music before I start; very powerful, I liked it, almost absurd in the organs strength, matching the arch humour throughout the work.
Lights usually come from back and behind, to mention. We have a camera crawling along walls, strokes in both directions, camera stylo writing, also moving up and down. 'Marienbad' as the anatomy of the track (smooth); dissection of role of that move, of a camera, as desire (When the eventual move backwards comes, falls off the wall, we have its reverse, a dissection, the negation of desire; what is that?).
These erotic tracks are not actually too explicit, then huge orgasm on ironic Italian melo burst in, repetition of a track into the feathered arms, one of the most powerful moments I know in the cinema.
Also worth to say that there are quite a few close views- and why not. That is the feeling, it conveys it.
Marienbad won't be reduced, but let me talk of specificity and abstraction. If time doesn't matter, nor does place; says the man, abstraction. Yet also, there is specificity in eroticism, among the interchangeable walls we have the one moment, the walk I made for you through carpets so thick we had silence. This is all in the same way the voice (over)/ poetry (Robbe-Grillet, yet also the words of some kind of characters)/ acting (mannered, singular, general stand-ins) is specific and abstract.
Where to start on the shadows of the garden; not for blocks, but specific humans? Too easy. The location is at once so clear, big blocks referenced in the final words, yet among them I lose you.
For all, in a way this is quite simple; man meets women, she can't remember, montage cuts between then and now, some maybe true, some not, all indeterminate, maybe, or specific in erotic. The only confusion is deliberate, the need, perhaps, for mystification, the way life is clear, clear blocks, but I still can't find you, the mystery of a white wall, a gaudy stucco. One just needs to accept continuous time has collapsed in the montage.
Returning to the key question of specificity; does time matter between moral decisions? Does what is in between matter? If there was a decision now, and then, does time exist between? What is going on in the cut, in impossible spaces where space is clearly 'unreal'? Does this matter, for life?
Is there a lack of politics here? This is a film from a director of the mouvelle vague, in some way; one occassioanlly realises, in the deliberate humour often, this is after all people dressing up. The nouvelle vague was horribly apolitical in many ways; and like them, you have to say Resnais at least centers erotiticism as much, if not more, than engagement (fatalism?). I would call this, if I could name things, a film about eroticism, really. But eroticism and politics are intertwined; the film is about eroticism in a degraded world, how it can only exist as deliberately obscured, confused, not making sense. This is the fetish element, shoes and bondage.
How can the specificity of desire manage in the degraded world of this hotel/ spa? Marienbad, Fredericksbad, twists these confusions, which are necessary. Desire only possible through what looks like heavy formalism; the only way to save it, by intellectualising it?
For all, there are clear politics; the spa (I want!) is clearly the bourgeois/ aristocracy, the fading abstractions of the brutal walls that enclose, only one way, that turn my footsteps to silence in the carpet, yet can be heard in the gravel that may or may not be under your window.
O.K., Resnais is allowed one symbol, and the quite funny game is perfect for capitalism; he can lose, but never does. Is this my favourite symbol in cinema? Clear, beautfiul, beyond simple unpacking.
The greatest film ever? Never a good phrase- it is on that highest plateau, which isn't even a plateau, but the unsayable.... The most erotic film (Dreyer?), moments of losing control, the voiceover in crashes of specificity. The most visually pleasing? Maybe. Perfectly formed location, architecture geometric and mysterirous, tracks around corners. The most intelligent? Visually, in literature, it achieves greatness.

Cria Cuervos

Carlos Saura - 1976
I mean, it's not terrible, but I can't really think of anything nice to say about it. Quite a heavy camera creeps around a bit, in pretty long takes, slowly moving in and out (though there is what I would describe as pointless cutting, perhaps down to inadequacies of framing). There is a hell of a lot of Kuleshoving with the little girl, her blank expression I suppose intended to be charming or meaningful, which I didn't really find. Th washes out palette is pretty ugly, not in a very interesting way.
Childhood / children can be interesting when considered from an adult perspective, used to cast light on an adult world; in itself, it is idiotic and boring. Harsh but fair, I think...

Sunday, 28 August 2011

Tartuffe

Friedrich Wilhelm Murnau - 1925
The often referred to 'mobile camera' of Murnau, and Freund, has often confused me, for, for all the innovations in movement, as an aesthetic principle it is pretty minimal in a lot of shots. But here I felt great mobility in the camera, despite its stillness; precisely because their is mobility in the set up; Murnau, as Griffiths, introduces the idea of the camera as being able to shoot from any point, any angle, not constrained by stage constaints. His camera can be below, behind, through a window, wherever.
This surprised me for the pace of the edit, and for how close the framings are. And I mean really close; facial close-ups even, medium shots could be as far out as we get for a few sequences. This is not what one expects of silent cinema. There is also some long stuff, on that slightly abstract, deeply beautiful studio set look that Murnau has, with light expressionism (cinematic, German) infusing the air; a kind of slightly lighter one than, say, Murnau's 'Faust'.
I didn't find this his most distinctive work, we basically have a tale set out in front of us (or around us, as above). Of course the compositions are [refect, hang-up able. I watched a copy with a lot of yellow tints, high contrasts, and pretty scratchy, faded sides. Also note we have the Murnau-ish back of the leering man.
The obvious point of interest is the framing device; why? There is quite a shock here. Is it modernist (why categorize?)? Yes and no. Yes, in that we are told 'Tartuffe' and asked explictly to reflect on it, consider even the morality of telling a tale. No in that what it sets up is simply a very middle-ages esque tale, pure and simple; it is a morality play, modernist only if you are being difficult.
There are recurring elements of Murnau found even in Moliere's story. The odd attitude towards woman, showing their power, yet disgust with them is obvious; as is a kind of lust (the director's sexuality notwithstanding, perhaps). Also the fear of unemployment, and the need to communicate, say something. This moral part (not that I necessarilly agree..), with the tale like structure, put me in mind of the slightly more detailed, though admittedly less ornate and baroque, 'Master Of The House'.

Saturday, 27 August 2011

Uwasa no Onna

Kenji Mizoguchi - 1954
Not concentrating hard enough. We have a very modern day, collision of people, in busy environments, quite loud people. Much of a sense of closeness, as the cuts, now almost portraiture, are a part of. This seems to gel with the overdetermined reasons for each sction, almost the cinfusion, the swirl of reasons, the tragic demeanours caught in this. Even within a struggling group we have internal conflict. ALso note the generally negative image of average man, though not all men; this examination is again and again found in the Mizoguchi I come across.

Gion Bayashi

Kenji Mizoguchi - 1953
The camera is getting closer with each one (which is silly, as this is before 'Sancho' in time, but anyway). Moving to quite a few at least mid shots; perhaps it is because it is modern day, less a tale, more a social analysis. It does keep the Mizoguchi looking and looked at, but it does some things differntly. This shift, when I think of my own reaction to it and something similar in Kurosawa, usually finds me an advocate of at least the equality of the modern day, against some critical opinion.
What I like, and I like this film very much, is how very specific it is. There is a kind of humour here, in the details; the lawyer, the legal codes given, the way the horror of the situation is reduced to these exact formulations (also congratulate the oppenness; anything better than Hollywood).
We have crushing fate again, which has cause, effect, solution, but is so built in as to be inevitable. It is pretty clear where Mizoguchi stands, hating the Geisha principles. One more thing; he can cut in, he does sometimes move in for tears. Just not always.

Friday, 26 August 2011

Der Letze Mann

Friedrich Wilhelm Murnau - 1924
So incredibly beautful, but not without difficulty, not too smooth or shiny. This is like a great ancient classical work; perfect, but with that air of the primitive.
More sepcifically, many low angles for the very strong whites, like on fire. The money is even white. This all goes with the themes of smoke throughout, hell... Deleuze.
We have a mixture of long shots, but the film seems at once modern for its mediums, more than I can think certainly most black and whites, nevermind silents... The edit is precise, but never pnderous, very exact moves, often nintety or one eighty.
In a way, this is two different films; we have a real change from the hotel to the housing estate; there we have remarkable non-centering, the windows come alive across the frame in that great early stil shot. I don't know what to say but the ridiculous; neo realism? Cramped interiors, everyday washing, life, little moves, dirty faces. There is a slightly odd attitude to the woman gossips, sympathetic but cruel...
The hotel is shot more precise ly, with those wonderful singular (literally) moves towards or away from an action. Also note similar moves for travelling sound; into the ear. The earline match.
And the epilogue; at first quite a smart inversion, of excess, moving the film from parochialism of a single kind of consciousness one could say, for all the obvious absurdity. Once this exercise is clear through, it becomes downright odd
This film is still for me sensational; just Jannings against that wall. Perhaps my favourite silent film; or just film, long with a few incomparable others.

Sancho Dayu

Kenji Mizoguchi - 1954
In many ways this is a play of looking, seen in distance what is looked at, with the back turned to the camera, and the look, seen close up, where we don't see the other half of this double. This, as in the famous boat scene, is used in variations for the appropriate effect. In this sense, editing is key for all this; a deliberate edit, not always tied to narrative extrapolation.
We have that lovely dappled forest throughout, and many huge long shots; a finish again on the notion of work, the singular plowing the field, or beach here. I again felt, with the mysticism, the wide open islands, the idea of powers swirling, not settling.
I can't help but have to bring up fatalism; throughout this and other works of Mizoguchi, perhaps? A pile up of problems, what I dislike is the dramatic arc to them, which gives me a feeling of a sense of relish to them. To be fair, specific problems are dealt with (slavery, land rights), but really it seems more like the principle of misery is more at play than anything.

Ugetsu Monogatari

Kenji Mizoguchi - 1953
The play is of long takes, small people, high and low in that wonderful environment full of reeds, rivers, mist, busy busy markets (people as mist). Through these we are moved pretty quickly, along the top and/or the bottom of the screen.
This is a film about male hubris, about pride, about ethics, what one wants, what is good, about art and that vocation. Ultimately, work cannot just be dismissed, for all the problems; the high shot of the workers at the end, the return to pottery. Yet Mizoguchi is a tragedian, and this comes with the price of a kind of eternal suffering.
The infusion of ghosts, of memory, is at its best when the mis-en-scene corresponds with the boats, and best yet with pans that move to dissolves, along the earth, that cross time and space; of course the famous, restrained pan around the house. Of course, this is a terrific film.

Thursday, 25 August 2011

Oyu - Sama

Kenji Mizoguchi - 1951
Mizoguchi's camera starts long, and can stay there. A mixture of stillness and movements, often those sideways movement that, along with zig zag compostions, non-geometrical framings (though he can do geometrical, perhaps because houses are so...) give that famous sense of a world beyond the frame (similar effect caused by entrances and exits). So he starts long, and tracks or pans along with the movements, usually. He does not though, ever seemingly, cut in for emphasis. If they are far away, they are far away, even if its an important plot point, they can be very far away, the camera not disturbing. The depth is very much a part, all in focus, using a wide stage. Ideas as to why later.
He can cut around sometimes, though this seems to follow a formal pattern (ninety degree moves, for example) before an emotional one, perhaps.
The film overexposes the light, but we only get the light dappled through trees, often at the tops of frames. Thus there is this hazy, mystical effect, through the leaves. It all seemed pretty soft to me. The framings don't give a sense of being exact, but I think they are; one movement can reveal the back of someone else's neck in a new light, or such things, a lot.
So how is the story told? An initial situation, not overmilked, then basically a pile-up of woe, never individually melodramatic but ultimately proving too much for tyhe charatcers. It can be surprisingly honest, or rather straightforward, about sex. There is also an ability to create awkwardness, discomfort, or simply the realistation of how someone else in the room is feeling. The time is passed with quite fast dissolves, often, sometimes in what are essentially silent montage sequences. There are also some lovely non-narrative bits, of empty rooms or flowers.
So what did this add up to for me? The reluctance to place or define an emotion. Not saying; 'this is tears, the emotion' but hiding any exact one for one. A world, a situation, is built, in which forces swirl. The moves off screen, the flow, the exits, are just one element where the emotion is not allowed to be singulaires (and neautralised), defined as one thing. It creates a very individual style.

The Roaring Twenties

Raoul Wlash - 1939
Wlash uses a pretty mobile camera, with some lovely flowing moves that establish the space then move closer into scenes, the cut only coming when the SRS starts. What I really liked about the look of the film was its architecure, and the chracters relation to it, often in longish shots. The actions are slightly stilited, and there is a wonderful sense of unreality about some of the sets, huge blank walls, at one point they seem to turn up on the set of 'The Trial', or maybe 'Metropolis'. There is something pleasing surrealist about a number of these scenes.
The story arc is generally of the classic gangster movie. In fact, one montage I'm pretty sure uses shots from 'Scarface'. I should talk about the montages. This is a self-conscious gangster movie, using all the epoch's trappings, and the montage of direct, superciliously grand narration flies us through impostions of scenes. Each element is way clearer, and probably a bit slower, than in, say, Russian montage. But, as with all these film, pleausre in the elegance.
Walsh, I have read, gets a lot of credit for little details; there are some nive touches here, little asides from one to another, but I largely found the studio setting too simple for a huge amount of this. Nevertheless, the psychologies are complex; some actions are not the obvious ones taken, all for the better.

Storm Over Asia

V.I. Pudovkin - 1928
Compared to your average work, this is a piece of the Soviet montage aesthetic. It frequently uses still, quite close shots, in fast excahnge, to convey its ideas. There is much evocation of place, here, largely the steppes. In many ways it reminded me of the great 'Earth', with these wide open spaces.
And like 'Earth', it is not exactly like one expects of the montage school. The takes are a bit longer, and here they are often not canted. There isn't much glorification of the human figure; even the capitalist is bad because we are told so, rather than from any paricular framing choise. There are some very long shots, and not short takes, of the steppes, along with just medium or full body stuff. The story, while not psychological, does have a main character, who conflicts with events (those he is buffeted aroumd rather than initially dcisive).
The end really is remaraklbe; incredibly quick cuts and effects, no sense of realistic space, powerful and stirring. There are some pretty noutceable effects throughout, either using gauzes or distorting angles, al combined with the classic Soviet lights from two sides approach. Half the film one might expect.

Wednesday, 24 August 2011

Gabbeh

Mohsen Makhmalbaf - 1996
Focus on colour, clearly. A mixture of very long shots, in pretty long takes, and some quite close moves, always still, between faces, to create the slightly magical continuity elements. The matches on action, where magic occurs, gives thought to one of the principle elements of this film, the idea of abundance; of image, of colour, of warmth, of people communicating.
Those great strong colours, centered in the frame and in the treatment, are the life against what is often a pretty arid looking background. They are the stuff of something called 'life'.
The plot is clearly a bit of magical realism, time colliding, a look back on a life by throwing past and future together to have a chat with each other. The plot functions very gently in the background, with the idea of the refrain being key, and the idea of narrative more than a logical working out. The film seems largely to want us to focus on colours, life, patience in this, people.

El Topo

Alejandro Jodorowsky - 1970
This, in mayn ways, looks a lot like a lot of films of its time, especially the American cinema, in Peckinpah ('The Wild Bunch' especially), and also in Leone and so on. This is the pretty flat canvas, zooming, or in this case perhaps more tracking, in and out with a wide angle lens. There are also, for all the pretty relaxed framings and sometimes not entirely smooth cameras, a penchant for central framing, very geometrical. Visually, we also have a lot of strong colours against the long horizontals, montomy of the sand.
Action here though is in what is being filmed. With pretty much a narrative, just surreal encounters reached. There is heavy use of symbolism, fetishism, often strong, comic book, quite deliberately unreal colours and images used. Sometimes people just start doing the darndest things. This is, in one sense, a little tiresome; rather like stripping Bunuel of what is actually Bunuel. But to be fair here there is a clear political accent, an attack, or rather a mockery of ways of life, practicies of racism and so on. This is counterculture. If rather too abstract to be really strong on this, well, it at least tries, rather more than can be said for some of what it has influenced.
Basically a melting plot of a kind of Christianity infued with Buddhist and Hindu leanings, this is really of its time; and not necessarilly too much the worse for that.

Tuesday, 23 August 2011

The Killing

Stanely Kubrick - 1956
Very early Kubrick; and very, very good Kubrick.
Clear influence of Welles, I would call it. Big deep spaces, often low angles. Overlapping dialogue, a 'Lady From Shanghai' level of speed between scenes, flying from one to another, cutting off. Also I detected a lot of Ophuls in the camera movements, and Hawks maybe also (also the pace with Hawks; 'Scarface', maybe?) in the horizontal tracks through rooms, through walls, starting scenes often (as in that great shot in 'La Signora Di Tutti'. From these openings, pretty long takes (as throughout), we often move to a quite deliberate SRS, a slightly weird one.
What Kubrick has added to these directors is certainly a great deal of precision; and this film is in many ways about precision. The famous narrative shattering is those pieces of a puzzle, helped of course by the quite funny narration. The film is partly about, and this could be a helpful key to Kubrick's work, the idea of the parts and the whole. If you add all the pieces of the puzzle (here), the actions of a romantic hero psychology (Lyndon), the psychological attributes of a human (2001), the causes of a society (Clockwork Orange... is this a bit desperate?), what do you get? Not the whole seemingly, because precision is... unreal? Impossible? How tightly can you plan?
Also, manipulation of time is key here. We have the return to one sequence, the horse race. The moves back, putting into place. It isn't actually too nuts, some suspense needs to be created, but there is some nice bits of seeing one seen from two angles, narrative wise. Also, it is remarkable in the final shooting scene how quickly it passes; he clearly extends time in some places, but here just flies through.
I loved the droleness here, partly in the very exact compositions, in the slight absurdities (nothing important in the bag!). Their is a weirdness here, again 'Lady From Shanghai' esque, unreal I suppose. It flies along, great fun. Some great individual scenes; I love all of them with the car park attendant.

Ashes And Diamonds

Andrzej Wajda - 1958
Very Wellesian, I felt. Constructing the space with huge fish-eye angles, very deep spaces. Often aggressively close to the camera, with surely on occassion projections to cope with some parts (the seperating of the frame, for example in the longer shot with the telephone, is presumably down to this). The setting to this is pretty mundane, and the better for that, showing a slightly grubby conference room, an average-ish day at a church at the start.
What happens in this film? Things aren't alright in Poland. No war heroes, no even clear villains, just a country with corruption and rather a lack of ideals. What kind of film can be made about this? This felt to me a pretty straightforward bit of art cinema, kind of worried ambiguous characters, a sort of story and psychology being told, very nice, a little dull.

Charlie Chaplin: Essanay Shorts

Charles Chaplin - 1915
His New Job, A Night Out, The Champion, The Tramp
Pretty early Chaplin. This is obviously in the earlier stages of the cinema, with the specific kind of oblong cinematic space, the (inaccurate) attempt to represent the theatre. Chaplin does use depth, but obviously the pinned against the wall horizontals are much more in place. Chaplin has mastered the continuity cut from space to spcae, as well as the match on action (I think); he can cut in in the middle of a scene, to get a better look, if on one angle. One interesting thing about the compositions is the Chaplin is not overly fussy, or perhaps even avoids, centered framings. Not that this is exactly 'Machorka-Muff', but it's just a little off-center in nearly all of them. The compositions are also very complex, with tiny actions, often a hand, not centered but revealing a gag, or even a 'plot' point all of their own.
To get to important matters; every location change, indeed every shot change, seems to reveal an entirely new location, even though the actions (i.e. direction of movement) can show it continous with the last. Moving to a road next to a forest, or a stage next to a dressing room, seems to give a new kind of way of living, a new way to approach life.
And approach life is what Chaplin's figure does, even before the Tramp is really developed. Using feet and hands, he intereacts with the world by striking against it. And he finds it difficult, he gets it wrong. Nearly everything in all these films relates to the difficulty in finding, keeping a job. Surviving employment. Everything else is rather secondary to this, which is revealed is difficult, extremely difficult. Obviously, the physical usages are not 'realistic' in one sense; yet that very physical idea of 'here I am, i am meant to do this, do that', is remarkable. It is the classic modernist position of defamiliaridation, in a way. And with this is combined some really subtle psychology; just a little look.